home | O'Reilly's CD bookshelfs | FreeBSD | Linux | Cisco | Cisco Exam    

Practical UNIX & Internet Security

Practical UNIX & Internet SecuritySearch this book
Previous: 16.1 Networking Chapter 16
TCP/IP Networks
Next: 16.3 IP Security

16.2 IPv4: The Internet Protocol Version 4

The Internet Protocol is the glue that holds together modern computer networks. IP specifies the way that messages are sent from computer to computer; it essentially defines a common "language" that is spoken by every computer stationed on the Internet.

This section describes IPv4, the fourth version of the Internet Protocol, which has been used on the Internet since 1982. As this book is going to press, work is continuing on IPv6, previously called "IP: The Next Generation," or IPng. (IPv5 was an experimental protocol that was never widely used.) We do not know when (or if) IPv6 will be widely used on the network.

As we said earlier, at a very abstract level the Internet is similar to the phone network. However, as we look more closely at the underlying protocols, we find that it is quite different. On the telephone network, each conversation is assigned a circuit (either a pair of wires or a channel on a multiplexed connection) that it uses for the duration of the telephone call. Whether you talk or not, the channel remains open until you hang up the phone.

On the Internet, the connections between computers are shared by all of the conversations. Data is sent in blocks of characters called datagrams, or more colloquially, packets. Each packet has a small block of bytes called the header, which identifies its sender and intended destination on each computer. The header is followed by another, usually larger, block of characters of data called the packet's contents . (See Figure 16.3 .) After the packets reach their destination, they are often reassembled into a continuous stream of data; this fragmentation and reassembly process is usually invisible to the user. As there are often many different routes from one system to another, each packet may take a slightly different path from source to destination. Because the Internet switches packets, instead of circuits, it is called a packet-switching network.

Figure 16.3: IP header and packet

Figure 16.3

We'll borrow an analogy from Vint Cerf, one of the original architects of the ARPANET : think of the IP protocol as sending a novel a page at a time, numbered and glued to the back of postcards. All the postcards from every user get thrown together and carried by the same trucks to their destinations, where they get sorted out. Sometimes, the postcards get delivered out of order. Sometimes, a postcard may not get delivered at all, but you can use the page numbers to request another copy. And, key for security, anyone in the postal service who handles the post cards can read the contents without the recipient or sender knowing about it.

There are three distinct ways to directly connect two computers together using IP:

  • The computers can all be connected to the same local area network. Two common LANS are Ethernet and token ring. Internet packets are then encapsulated within the packets used by the local area network.[4]

    [4] LANs and token rings can also carry protocols other than IP (including Novell IPX and Appletalk), often at the same time as IP network traffic.

  • Two computers can be directly connected to each other with a serial line. IP packets are then sent using either SLIP (Serial Line Internet Protocol), CSLIP (Compressed SLIP ), or PPP (Point-to-Point Protocol). If both computers are each in turn connected to a local area network, the telephone link will bridge together the two LANS . (See Figure 16.4 .)

  • The IP packets can themselves be encapsulated within packets used by other network protocols. Today, many 56K "leased lines" are actually built by encapsulating IP packets within Frame Relay packets. Within a few years, IP may be commonly encapsulated within ATM (Asynchronous Transfer Mode) networks.[5]

    [5] If our use of all these network terms is causing your eyes to roll back into your head and a loud buzzing sound to fill your ears, take a break and several deep breaths. Then consult a book on IP and networks for a more complete explanation. We recommend the excellent Internetworking with TCP/IP by Doug Comer (Prentice Hall, 1991).

Figure 16.4: Bridging two local area networks

Figure 16.4

IP is a scalable network protocol: it works as well with a small office network of ten workstations as it does with a university-sized network supporting a few hundred workstations, or with the national (and international) networks that support tens of thousands of computers. IP scales because it views these large networks merely as collections of smaller ones. Computers connected to a network are called hosts. Computers that are connected to two or more networks can be programmed to forward packets automatically from one network to another; today, these computers are called routers (originally they were called gateways ). Routers use routing tables to determine where to send packets next.

16.2.1 Internet Addresses

Every interface that a computer has on an IP network is assigned a unique 32-bit address. These addresses are often expressed as a set of four 8-bit numbers, called octets. A sample address is Think of an IP address as if it were a telephone number: if you know a computer's IP address, you can connect to it and exchange information.

Theoretically, the 32-bit IP address allows a maximum of 232 = 4,294,967,296 computers to be attached to the Internet at a given time. In practice, the total number of computers that can be connected is much less, because of the way that IP addresses are assigned. Organizations are usually assigned blocks of addresses, not all of which are used. This approach is similar to the method by which the phone company assigns area codes to a region. The approach has led to a problem with IP addresses similar to that faced by the telephone company: we're running out of numbers.

Here are some more sample Internet addresses:

IP addresses are typically abbreviated ii.jj.kk.ll, where the numbers ii, jj, kk, and ll are between 0 and 255. Each decimal number represents an 8-bit octet. Together, they represent the 32-bit IP address. IP networks

The Internet is a network of networks. Although most people think of these networks as major networks, such as those belonging to companies like AT&T, MCI , and Sprint, the networks that make up the Internet are actually local area networks, such as the network in your office building or the network in a small research laboratory. Each of these small networks is given its own network number.

There are two methods of looking at network numbers. The "classical" network numbers were distinguished by a unique prefix of bits in the address of each host in the network. This approach partitioned the address space into a well-defined set of different size networks. However, several of these networks had large "holes" - sets of host addresses that were never used. With the explosion of sites on the Internet, a somewhat different interpretation of network addresses has been proposed, to result in some additional addresses that can be assigned to networks and hosts. This approach is the CIDR ( Classless InterDomain Routing ) scheme. We briefly describe both schemes below.

The CIDR method may not be adequate to provide addresses for all the expected hosts on the network; therefore, as we've mentioned, a new protocol, IPv6, is being developed. This new protocol will provide a bigger address space for hosts and networks, and will provide some additional security features. Host addresses will be 128 bits long in IPv6. As this book goes to press, the features of IPv6 are not completely finalized, so we won't try to detail them here.[6]

[6] But you can be sure we'll cover them in the next edition! Classical network addresses

There are five primary kinds of IP addresses in the "classical" address scheme; the first few bits of the address (the most significant bits) define the class of network to which the address belongs. The remaining bits are divided into a network part and a host part:

Class A addresses

Hosts on Class A networks have addresses in the form N.a.b.c , where N is the network number and a.b.c is the host number; the most significant bit of N must be zero. There are not many Class A networks, as they are quite wasteful: unless your network has 16,777,216 separate hosts, you don't need a Class A network. Nevertheless, many early pioneers of the Internet, such as MIT and Bolt Beranek and Newman ( BBN ), have been assigned Class A networks. Of course, these organizations don't really put all of their computers on the same piece of network. Instead, most of them divide their internal networks as (effectively) Class B or Class C networks. This approach is known as subnetting .

Class B addresses

Hosts on Class B networks have addresses in the form N.M.a.b , where N.M is the network number and a.b is the host number; the most significant two bits of N must be 10. Class B networks are commonly found at large universities and major commercial organizations.

Class C addresses

Hosts on Class C networks have addresses in the form N.M.O.a , where N.M.O is the network number and a is the host number; the most significant three bits of N must be 110. These networks can only accommodate a maximum of 254 hosts. (Flaws and incompatibilities between various UNIX IP implementations make it unwise to assign IP addresses ending in 0 or 255.) Most organizations have one or more Class C networks.

Class D addresses

A Class D address is of the form N.M.O.a , where the most significant four bits of N are 1110. These addresses are not actually of networks, but of multicast groups - sets of hosts that listen on a common address to receive broadcast addresses.

Class E addresses

A Class E address is of the form N.M.O.P , where the most significant four bits of N are 1111. These addresses are currently reserved for experimental use. CIDR addresses

In recent years, a new form of address assignment has been developed. This assignment is the CIDR , or Classless InterDomain Routing , method. As the name implies, there are no "classes" of addresses as in the classical scheme. Instead, networks are defined as being the most significant k bits of each address, with the remaining 32-k bits being used for the host part of the address. Thus, a service provider could be given a range of addresses whereby the first 12 bits of the address are fixed at a particular value (the network address), and the remaining 20 bits represent the host portion of the address. This method allows the service provider to allocate up to 220 distinct addresses to customers.

In reality, the host portion of an address is further divided into subnets. This subdivision is done by fixing the first j bits of the host portion of the address to some set value, and using the remaining bits for host addresses. And those can be further divided into subnets, and so on. A CIDR -format address is of the form k.j.l.(m...n), where each of the fields is of variable length. Thus, the fictional service-provider network address described above could be subdivided into 1024 subnets, one for each customer. Each customer would have 210 bits of host address, which they could further subdivide into local subnets.

The CIDR scheme is compatible with the classical address format, with Class A addresses using an 8-bit network field, Class B networks using a 16-bit network address, and so on. CIDR is being adopted as this book goes to press. Combined with new developments in IP address rewriting, there is the potential to spread out the useful life of IPv4 for many years to come.

16.2.2 Routing

Despite the complexity of the Internet and addressing, computers can easily send each other messages across the global network. To send a packet, most computers simply set the packet's destination address and then send the packet to a computer on their local network called a gateway. If the gateway makes a determination of where to send the packet next, the gateway is a router. The router takes care of sending the packet to its final destination by forwarding the packet on to a directly connected gateway that is one step closer to the destination host.

Many organizations configure their internal networks as a large tree. At the root of the tree is the organization's connection to the Internet. When a gateway receives a packet, it decides whether to send it to one of its own subnetworks, or to direct it towards the root.

Out on the Internet, major IP providers such as AT&T , BBN Planet, MCI , and Sprint have far more complicated networks with sophisticated routing algorithms. Many of these providers have redundant networks, so that if one link malfunctions other links can take over.

Nevertheless, from the point of view of any computer on the Internet, routing is transparent, regardless of whether packets are being sent across the room or across the world. The only information that you need to know to make a connection to another computer on the Internet is the computer's 32-bit IP address - you do not need to know the route to the host, or on what type of network the host resides. You do not even need to know if the host is connected by a high-speed local area network, or if it is at the other end of a modem-based SLIP connection. All you need to know is its address, and your packets are on their way.

Of course, if you are the site administrator and you are configuring the routing on your system, you do need to be concerned with a little more than the IP number of a destination machine. You must know at least the addresses of gateways out of your network so you can configure your routing tables. We'll assume you know how to do that,[7] but we will point out that if your routes are fairly stable and simple, you would be safer by statically setting the routes rather than allowing them to be set dynamically with a mechanism such as the routed daemon.

[7] If not, you should consult your vendor manual, or one of the references in Appendix D, Paper Sources .

16.2.3 Hostnames

A hostname is the name of a computer on the Internet. Hostnames make life easier for users: they are easier to remember than IP addresses. You can change a computer's IP address but keep its hostname the same. If you think of an IP address as a computer's phone number, think of its hostname as the name under which it is listed in the telephone book. Some hosts can also have more than one address on more than one network. Rather than needing to remember each one, you can remember a single hostname and let the underlying network mechanisms pick the most appropriate addresses to use.

Let us repeat that: a single hostname can have more than one IP address, and a single IP address can be associated with more than one hostname. Both of these facts have profound implications for people who are attempting to write secure network programs.

Hostnames must begin with a letter or number and may contain letters, numbers, and a few symbols, such as the dash (-). Case is ignored. A sample hostname is arthur.cs.purdue.edu . For more information on host names, see RFC 1122 and RFC 1123.

Each hostname has two parts: the computer's machine name and its domain . The computer's machine name is the name to the left of the first period; the domain name is everything to the right of the first period. In our example above, the machine name is arthur and the domain is cs.purdue.edu . The domain name may represent further hierarchical domains if there is a period in the name. For instance, cs.purdue.edu represents the Computer Sciences department domain, which is part of the Purdue University domain, which is, in turn, part of the Educational Institutions domain.

Here are some other examples:

whitehouse.gov next.cambridge.ma.us jade.tufts.edu

If you specify a machine name, but do not specify a domain, then your computer might append a default domain when it tries to resolve the name's IP address. Alternatively, your computer might simply return an "unknown host" error message. The /etc/hosts file

Early UNIX systems used a single file called /etc/hosts to keep track of the network address for each host on the Internet. Many systems still use this file today to keep track of the IP addresses of computers on the organization's LAN .

A sample /etc/hosts file for a small organization might look like this:

# /etc/hosts 
# server art science sci engineering eng 

In this example, the computer called server has the network address The computer called engineering has the address The hostname sci following the computer called science means that sci can be used as a second name, or alias, for that computer.

In the early 1980s, the number of hosts on the Internet started to jump from thousands to tens of thousands and more. Maintaining a single file of host names and addresses soon proved to be impossible. Instead, the Internet adopted a distributed system for hostname resolution known as the Domain Name System ( DNS ). For more information, see the "Name Service" section later in this chapter.

16.2.4 Packets and Protocols

Today there are four main kinds of IP packets that are sent on the Internet that will be seen by typical hosts. Each is associated with a particular protocol:[8]

[8] There may be some special routing or maintenance protocols in use on the Internet backbone or other major network trunks. However, we won't discuss them here as you are unlikely to ever encounter them.


Internet Control Message Protocol. This protocol is used for low-level operation of the IP protocol. There are several subtypes, for example, for the exchange of routing and traffic information.


Transmission Control Protocol. This protocol is used to create a two-way stream connection between two computers. It is a "connected" protocol, and includes time-outs and retransmission to ensure reliable delivery of information.


User Datagram Protocol.[9] This protocol is used to send packets from host to host. The protocol is "connectionless" and makes a best-effort attempt at delivery.

[9] UDP does not stand for Unreliable Datagram Protocol, even though the protocol is technically unreliable because it does not guarantee that information sent will be delivered. We use the term best-effort because the underlying network infrastructure is expected to make its best effort to get the packets to their destination. In fact, most UDP packets reach their destination under normal operating circumstances.


Internet Group Management Protocol. This protocol is used to control multicasting - the process of purposely directing a packet to more than one host. Multicasting is the basis of the Internet's multimedia backbone, the MBONE . (Currently, IGMP is not used inside the MBONE , but is used on the edge.) ICMP

The Internet Control Message Protocol is used to send messages between gateways and hosts regarding the low-level operation of the Internet. For example, ICMP Echo packets are commonly used to test for network connectivity; the response is usually either an ICMP Echo Reply or an ICMP Destination Unreachable message type. ICMP packets are identified by an 8-bit TYPE field (see Table 16.1 ):

Table 16.1: ICMP Packet Types

TYPE Field

ICMP Message Type


Echo Reply (used by ping )


Destination Unreachable


Source Quench


Redirect (change a route)


Echo Request (used by ping )


Router Advertisement


Router Solicitation


Time Exceeded for a Datagram


Parameter Problem on a Datagram


Timestamp Request


Timestamp Reply


Information Request (obsolete)


Information Reply (obsolete)


Address-Mask Request


Address-Mask Reply

Although we have included all types for completeness, the most important types for our purposes are types 3, 4, and 5. An attacker can craft ICMP packets with these fields to redirect your network traffic away, or to perform a denial of service. If you use a firewall (discussed in Chapter 21, Firewalls ), you will want to be sure that these types are blocked or monitored. TCP

TCP provides a reliable, ordered, two-way transmission stream between two programs that are running on the same or different computers. "Reliable" means that every byte transmitted is guaranteed to reach its destination (or you are notified that the transmission failed), and that each byte arrives in the order in which it is sent. Of course, if the connection is physically broken, bytes that have not yet been transmitted will not reach their destination unless an alternate route can be found. In such an event, the computer's TCP implementation will send an error message to the process that is trying to send or receive characters, rather than give the impression that the link is still operational.

Each TCP connection is attached at each end to a port . Ports are identified by 16-bit numbers. Indeed, at any instant, every connection on the Internet can be identified by a set of two 32-bit numbers and two 16-bit numbers:

  • Host address of the connection's originator

  • Port number of the connection's originator

  • Host address of the connection's target

  • Port number of the connection's target

For example, Figure 16.5 shows three people on three separate workstations logged into a server using the rlogin program. Each process's TCP connection starts on a different host and at a different originating port number, but each connection terminates on the same host (the server) and the same port (513).

Figure 16.5: A few Internet connections with port numbers

Figure 16.5

The idea that the workstations are all connecting to port number 513 can be confusing. Nevertheless, these are all distinct connections, because each one is coming from a different originating host-port pair, and the server moves each connection to a separate, higher-numbered port.

The TCP protocol uses two special bits in the packet header, SYN and ACK , to negotiate the creation of new connections. To open a TCP connection, the requesting host sends a packet that has the SYN bit set but does not have the ACK bit set. The receiving host acknowledges the request by sending back a packet that has both the SYN and the ACK bits set. Finally, the originating host sends a third packet, again with the ACK bit set, but this time with the SYN bit unset. This process is called the TCP " three-way handshake," and is shown in Figure 16.6 . By looking for packets that have the ACK bit unset, one can distinguish packets requesting new connections from those which are being sent in response to connections that have already been created. This distinction is useful when constructing packet filtering firewalls, as we shall see in Chapter 21 .

Figure 16.6: The TCP/IP "three-way handshake"

Figure 16.6

TCP is used for most Internet services which require the sustained synchronous transmission of a stream of data in one or two directions. For example, TCP is used for remote terminal service, file transfer, and electronic mail. TCP is also used for sending commands to displays using the X Window System.

Table 16.2 identifies some TCP services commonly enabled on UNIX machines. These services and port numbers are usually found in the /etc/services file.[10] (Note that non -UNIX hosts can run most of these services; the protocols are usually specified independent of any particular implementation.)

[10] A more extensive list of TCP and UDP ports and services may be found in Appendix G, Table of IP Services .

Table 16.2: Some Common TCP Services and Ports

TCP Port

Service Name




Echoes characters (for testing)



Discards characters (for testing)



Time of day



Character generator



File Transfer Protocol (FTP)



Virtual terminal



Electronic mail



Time of day



TCP nameservice



NIC whois service



Domain Name Service (DNS)



User information



World Wide Web (WWW)



Post Office Protocol (POP)



Post Office Protocol (POP)



Sun Microsystem's Remote Procedure Call (RPC)



Authentication Service



Network News Transfer Protocol (NNTP) (Usenet)



NeXTSTEP Window Server



Executes commands on a remote UNIX host



Logs in to a remote UNIX host



Retrieves a shell on a remote UNIX host



Remote printing



Runs UUCP over TCP/IP (primarily used for transporting netnews)



NFS over TCP



X Window System UDP

The User Datagram Protocol provides a simple, unreliable system for sending packets of data between two or more programs running on the same or different computers. "Unreliable" means that the operating system does not guarantee that every packet sent will be delivered, or that packets will be delivered in order. UDP does make its best effort to deliver the packets, however. On a LAN , UDP often approaches 100% reliability.

UDP 's advantage is that it has less overhead than TCP  - less overhead lets UDP -based services transmit information with as much as 10 times the throughput. UDP is used primarily for Sun's Network Filesystem, for NIS , for resolving hostnames, and for transmitting routing information. It is also used for services that aren't affected negatively if they miss an occasional packet because they will get another periodic update later, or because the information isn't really that important. This includes services such as rwho, talk, and some time services.

UDP packets are often broadcast to a given port on every host that resides on the same local area network. Broadcast packets are used frequently for services such as time of day.

As with TCP , UDP packets are also sent from a port on the sending host to another port on the receiving host. Each UDP packet also contains user data. If a program is listening to the particular port and is ready for the packet, it will be received. Otherwise, the packet will be ignored.

Ports are identified by 16-bit numbers. Table 0-71 lists some common UDP ports.

Table 16.3: Some Common UDP Services and Ports

UDP Port

Service Name




Returns the user's data in another datagram



Does nothing



Returns time of day



Character Generator



Returns time of day



Domain Name Service (DNS)



Trivial File Transfer Protocol (TFTP)



Sun Microsystem's Remote Procedure Call (RPC) portmapper



Network Time Protocol (NTP)



Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP)



Alerts you to incoming mail (Biff was the name of a dog who barked when the mailman came)



Returns who is logged into the system



System logging facility



Initiates a talk request



The "new" talk request



Routing Information Protocol (RIP)



Write on every user's terminal


NFS (usually)

Network Filesystem (NFS)

16.2.5 Clients and Servers

The Internet Protocol is based on the client/server model. Programs called clients initiate connections over the network to other programs called servers, which wait for the connections to be made. One example of a client/server pair is the network time system. The client program is the program that asks the network server for the time. The server program is the program that listens for these requests and transmits the correct time. In UNIX parlance, server programs that run in the background and wait for user requests are often known as daemons .

Clients and servers are normally different programs. For example, if you wish to log onto another machine, you can use the telnet program:

telnet athens.com

Connected to ATHENS.COM 
Escape character is '^]'.  

4.4 BSD Unix (ATHENS.COM)  


When you type telnet, the client telnet program on your computer (usually the program /usr/bin/telnet , or possibly /usr/ucb/telnet ) connects to the telnet server (in this case, named /usr/etc/in.telnetd) running on the computer athens.com . As stated, clients and servers normally reside in different programs. One exception to this rule is the sendmail program, which includes the code for both the server and a client, bundled together in a single application.

The telnet program can also be used to connect to any other TCP port that has a process listening. For instance, you might connect to port 25 (the SMTP port) to fake some mail without going through the normal mailer:

telnet control.mil 25

Trying ...
Connected to hq.control.mil.
Escape character is '^]'.
220-hq.control.mil Sendmail 8.6.10 ready at Tue, 17 Oct 1995 20:00:09 -0500
220 ESMTP spoken here

HELO kaos.org

250 hq.control.mil Hello kaos.org, pleased to meet you

MAIL FROM:<agent86@control.gov>

250 <agent86>... Sender ok

RCPT TO:<agent99@control.mil>

550 <agent99>... Recipient ok


354 Enter mail, end with "." on a line by itself

To: agent99
From: Max <agent86>
Subject: tonight

I know I was supposed to take you out to dinner tonight, but I have
been captured by KAOS agents, and they won't let me out until they
finish torturing me. I hope you understand. 
Love, Max

250 UAA01441 Message accepted for delivery


221 hq.control.mil closing connection
Connection closed by foreign host.

16.2.6 Name Service

As we mentioned, in the early days of the Internet, a single /etc/hosts file contained the address and name of each computer on the Internet. But as the file grew to contain thousands of lines, and as changes to the list of names (or the namespace) started being made on a daily basis, a single /etc/hosts file soon became impossible to maintain. Instead, the Internet developed a distributed networked-based naming service called the Domain Name Service ( DNS ).

DNS implements a large-scale distributed database for translating hostnames into IP addresses and vice-versa, and performing related name functions. The software performs this function by using the network to resolve each part of the hostname distinctly. For example, if a computer is trying to resolve the name girigiri.gbrmpa.gov.au , it would first get the address of the root domain server (usually stored in a file) and ask that machine for the address of the au domain server. The computer would then ask the au domain server for the address of the gov.au domain server, and then would ask that machine for the address of the gbrmpa.gov.au domain server. Finally, the computer would then ask the gbrmpa.gov.au domain server the address for the computer called girigiri.gbrmpa.gov.au . (Name resolution is shown in Figure 16.7 .) A variety of caching techniques are employed to minimize overall network traffic.

Figure 16.7: The DNS tree hierarchy for name resolution

Figure 16.7

DNS is based on UDP , but can also use a TCP connection for some operations. DNS under UNIX

The standard UNIX implementation of DNS is called bind and was originally written at the University of California at Berkeley. This implementation is based on three parts: a library for the client side, and two programs for the server:


The resolver library uses DNS to implement the gethostbyname() and gethost-byaddress() library calls. It is linked into any program that needs to perform name resolution using DNS . The first time that a program linked with the resolver attempts to resolve a hostname, the library reads the /etc/resolv.conf file to determine the IP address of the nameserver to be used for name resolution. The resolv.conf file can also contain the program's default domain, which is used to resolve unqualified hostnames (such as girigiri , as opposed to girigiri.gbrmpa.gov.au ).

named (or in.named)

The named daemon is the program which implements the server side of the DNS system. When named is started, it reads a boot file (usually /etc/named.boot) that directs the program to the location of its auxiliary files. These files then initialize the named daemon with the location of the root domain servers. If the named daemon is the nameserver for a domain or a subdomain (which is usually the case), the configuration file instructs the program to read in the domain's host tables or get them from a "master" server.


Program used to transfer zones from primary to secondary servers. This program is usually installed as /etc/named-xfer. It is run by the secondary server to perform a zone transfer. The named-xfer program connects to the named program running on the primary server and performs the transfer using TCP .

More details about DNS and the BIND name server may be found in the O'Reilly & Associates book DNS and BIND by Paul Albitz and Cricket Liu. Other naming services

In addition to DNS , there are at least four vendor-specific systems for providing nameservice and other information to networked workstations. They are:

NIS (Sun Microsystems)

Originally called "Yellow Pages," Sun's Network Information System ( NIS ) creates a simple mechanism whereby files such as /etc/passwd and /etc/hosts from one computer can be shared by another. Although NIS has numerous security problems, it is widely used. [11]

[11] We describe NIS and NIS+ in more detail in Chapter 19, RPC, NIS, NIS+, and Kerberos .

NIS + (Sun Microsystems)

NIS + is a total rewrite of NIS , and it dramatically increases both security and flexibility. Nevertheless, NIS + is not used as widely as NIS .

NetInfo (NeXT, Inc.)

NetInfo is a distributed database similar to NIS +. NetInfo is tightly integrated in NeXT's NEXTSTEP operating system and is available for other operating systems from a third party.

DCE (Open Software Foundation)

OSF 's Distributed Computing Environment offers yet another system for distributing a database of information, such as usernames and hosts addresses, to networked workstations.

All of these systems are designed to distribute a variety of administrative information throughout a network. All of these systems must also use DNS to resolve hostnames outside the local organization.